AI is a supplement, not a replacement, for human-generated content. AI can only regurgitate information, thoughts, and ideas that already exist.
Overall, Gemini seems to go above and beyond in all areas of content generation—besides image generation.
We recommend exploring how AI tools can benefit your business without replacing human contributions.
Artificial intelligence (AI) isn’t going anywhere anytime soon, and while it’s pretty terrifying to think about what AI will be capable of in the future, we still need to fully understand how AI can support our marketing goals and business growth today.
We’ve already outlined the dos and don’ts of using AI for marketing. Use AI to:
But, when it comes to choosing an AI platform…which do we recommend?
Our team—like most people—has heard a lot about ChatGPT, and has experimented with that tool for various tasks.
But Gemini—the AI platform formerly known as Bard—is making some major waves in the world of AI, and we wanted to dive in and do some comparative analysis.
Technically speaking, ChatGPT and Gemini are built on two different language platforms. ChatGPT uses GPT4 or GPT3.5, based on whether you are a free or premium user. Gemini uses—you guessed it—Gemini, or Gemini Ultra if you’re a premium user.
The difference in these language models is in the user experience. ChatGPT is more conversational—think of using ChatGPT like chatting with a subject-matter expert to solve a problem. Gemini, on the other hand, will process information and automate tasks in a more streamlined and time-efficient manner.
In terms of where each of these platforms retrieves its information, ChatGPT is still drawing solely from its training data, where Gemini is hooked in with Google itself. This means that ChatGPT may be relying on outdated information, where Gemini, by default, uses the latest and greatest.
From a technical standpoint—despite Gemini’s most recent and impressive updates, and the fact that it draws directly from Google’s knowledge base—experts are giving ChatGPT the leg-up on the who’s-better-than-who AI contest…
But it ain’t over ‘til it’s over…
Technical, schmechnical. We want to know which platform can do a better job of generating content.
We put these two platforms to the test to see which was more helpful with our marketing needs, and boy, the differences in ability between these two platforms is stark.
Let’s start with blog writing.
First, we want to reiterate that AI should be used to supplement human-generated content, or even vice versa. AI can only regurgitate information, thoughts, and ideas that already exist. For your content to be even remotely valuable to readers, you must infuse it with your own expertise, experience, authority, and thought. E-E-A-T. Look it up.
That being said, we don’t use AI to write blogs for our clients, or even for our own business. We never will. However, many businesses do use AI to write blogs, so we wanted to evaluate the difference between ChatGPT and Gemini when it comes to this particular application.
When prompted with “Write a blog on the benefits of using AI in marketing,” I was pleasantly surprised with Gemini’s response, but not super impressed with ChatGPT’s output. Gemini’s blog addressed the important point that AI is not a replacement for human creativity, but rather an assistant. Gemini’s version also discussed drawbacks to using AI, and mentioned a few tips for using AI to successfully generate content. ChatGPT’s response lacked this perspective.
We also found that Gemini’s output was more copy-and-paste ready (but remember, an AI-generated blog is not complete without human input), where ChatGPT’s response needed to be edited, even just to remove section headlines, such as Title and Conclusion.
And the winner is: Gemini.
Now, let’s talk about ChatGPT vs. Gemini in terms of creating templates and tools designed to keep your company’s marketing strategy on track.
We asked both platforms to create a template for a social media content calendar. This type of template could be extremely valuable for businesses in the process of developing a social media marketing strategy.
Gemini produced a template that addresses several components of the social media content curation process, including content type, topic, and call-to-action. While Gemini offered some suggestions about what to consider before getting started, as well as some tips for a successful social media marketing strategy, the platform also seemed to recognize its own limitations, and recommended a few well-known sites that could provide further assistance, such as Hootsuite and Sprout Social.
ChatGPT’s template, on the other hand, was quite limited. It simply listed the date, platform, and type of post, such as “blog” or “quote.” As a stand-alone template, there is a great deal of information and guidance missing. While ChatGPT did offer guidance about what to include in the social media calendar template, the template itself would need some attention before it could be truly useful.
Take a look for yourself.
Gemini’s output:
ChatGPT’s output:
And the winner is: Gemini.
As a premium ChatGPT user, you can ask the platform to generate images. Turns out, ChatGPT does a great job processing audio and visual data to generate images that do a great job of managing the spacial relationship between two or more objects. The creative output is actually quite impressive.
Gemini, as you may have heard, quickly shut down its image generation capabilities due to inaccuracies in depicting skin color and race. Essentially, Gemini was only generating images of multicultural or racially diverse people. The Pope, George Washington, and vikings were all depicted as people of color. And while we are happy to see Google trying to address diversity issues in marketing, accuracy is also important.
We are interested to see how Gemini ultimately addresses this issue, but using ChatGPT (or AI image generators built into stock photography platforms or Canva, etc.) has been a game changer. Stock photography has long been the bane of any graphic designer’s existence, so the ability to quickly generate images that depict exactly what we’re looking for has been incredibly valuable.
And the winner (by forfeit) is: ChatGPT.
Lastly, SEO keyword research is an important part of creating a successful digital marketing strategy, and AI has proven useful in identifying keywords and phrases to optimize for. Let’ see what happens when we pit ChatGPT vs. Gemini to assist in keyword research for a potential blog.
ChatGPT provided the keywords and a brief explanation to explain its choices. Gemini provided the keywords, the search volume for each term, brief explanations to support its choices, and even added a bonus tip for consideration.
And the winner (by a landslide) is: Gemini.
Overall, Gemini seems to go above and beyond in all areas of content generation—besides image generation, of course. In our experimentation, Gemini consistently generated more detailed responses, while ChatGPT’s responses seem to always be missing some key piece of information.
Even though we will never use AI to replace human-generated content, we do recommend exploring Gemini to see how this AI tool may benefit your business.
Not gonna lie, at Birdhouse Marketing & Design, we were really curious about whether our blog writing services would remain viable with the advent and proliferation of AI-generated content. The value of working with a team like ours is that we connect one-on-one with our clients to gain insight into their unique experiences. For example, we start by identifying a blog topic based on SEO trends, and then talk to our client to gather anecdotes and personal experiences that AI could never even begin to generate.
That’s what we call up-leveling your content marketing strategy.
If you’re ready to up-level your content marketing strategy, have your people get in touch with our people today.
Consumers are exposed to somewhere between 4,000 and 10,000 marketing messages a day, and yet business owners still expect them to travel neatly down a well-defined marketing funnel. Awareness, consideration, decision…right? Well, the truth is: the marketing funnel is dead, and it has been for some time now.
Fear-based marketing is probably my least favorite type of marketing. I’m very much a focus-on-the-solution kinda marketer. But using fear in marketing is nothing new, and it does have its place…but you have to know how much fear you can monger without crossing the line, when to leverage fear-based marketing, and when to keep it positive.
We have so much more where this came from! Subscribe to our email list for marketing tips, tricks, and advice—straight from our experts to your inbox.